VPN reviews
Each review is built from the public record: who owns the service, where its company is registered, which independent audits it has paid for, what has gone wrong, and what it costs on its own pricing page. We say what we did not test.
Verdict: Strong
ExpressVPN
Named auditors (KPMG, PwC, Cure53, Praetorian), an open-source protocol and a 2017 seizure that found no logs; the 2024 DNS bug was fixed and checked.
See pricing page Strong Gibraltar · IVPN LimitedIVPN
Eight annual independent audits, a named sole owner, open-source apps and a transparency report showing no data handed over; its limits are network size and features.
$5.00/mo Strong Sweden · Amagicom ABMullvad VPN
A 2023 police search that left with nothing, more than ten named security audits and founder ownership with no outside investors; the trade-offs are features, not trust.
€5.00/mo Strong Panama · Nord SecurityNordVPN
Six no-logs assurance reports from PwC and Deloitte since 2018, plus app and infrastructure audits, outweigh a 2018 breach that was disclosed late but contained.
See pricing page Strong Switzerland · Proton AG (largest voting shareholder: the non-profit Proton Foundation)Proton VPN
Five consecutive annual no-logs audits, open-source apps and a Swiss foundation as controlling shareholder; the one well-known legal case involved Proton Mail, not the VPN.
$2.99/mo Strong Netherlands · Nord Security (shared holding company)Surfshark
Two Deloitte no-logs reports (2023, 2025), app and server audits by Cure53 and SecuRing, and no public breach on record.
$2.49/mo StrongVerdict: Good
CyberGhost VPN
Three Deloitte no-logs reports (2022, 2024, 2025) and no known breach, but no published app security audit and no court-tested record.
$2.19/mo Good United States · Kape TechnologiesPrivate Internet Access (PIA)
Court-tested no-logs claim, open-source apps and three Deloitte reports; held back from Strong by no published app security audit and US jurisdiction.
$2.03/mo Good Canada (Toronto-based; parent company in the US) · McAfeeTunnelBear
Cure53 security audits published since 2017 and a clear privacy policy, held back from Strong by McAfee ownership, no no-logs assurance report and a narrow refund policy.
$3.33/mo Good Canada (Ontario) · Windscribe LimitedWindscribe
A court case dismissed with no logs to hand over, open-source apps and RAM-only servers, held back from Strong by a thin public audit record and a tight refund policy.
$5.75/mo GoodVerdict: Mixed
IPVanish
Three no-logs audits since 2022 count for a lot, but the 2016 handover of connection data contradicted its policy, and it remains a US company.
See pricing page Mixed Norway (Opera Norway AS is the data controller) · Opera Limited (controlled by Kunlun Tech)Opera VPN (browser VPN and VPN Pro)
The free VPN is convenient and no-account, but it covers only the browser, its claimed Deloitte audit isn't published, Pro runs on an unnamed third party's servers, and Opera is majority-controlled by Kunlun Tech.
$3.33/mo Mixed Sweden · PrivateVPN Global ABPrivateVPN
Useful features and a clear no-logs statement, but no independent audit, no public test of its claims and no disclosed owners behind the operating company.
$2.00/mo Mixed British Virgin Islands · GZ Systems LimitedPureVPN
Repeated no-log audits since 2019, but in 2017 it linked a customer's home and work IPs for the FBI, and its newest audit doesn't name the auditor.
$1.49/mo Mixed